Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in New York City: Our Top 16 Recommendations

Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in New York City: Our Top 16 Recommendations


If you're searching for reliable car insurance in New York City, you're in the right place! We've done extensive research to bring you the best local car insurance agencies. We evaluated each agency based on more than 25 variables across five categories, including licensing, user reviews, and service quality through mystery shopping calls. Our goal is to connect you with the best professionals, and after reviewing thousands of options, we've curated a list of the top 16 car insurance agencies in NYC.

How We Selected the Top Agencies

  • 4780 Agencies Reviewed
  • 2874 Agencies Curated
  • 16 Top Picks

We meticulously assessed each agency's customer service, reputation, coverage options, and overall customer satisfaction. Below, you'll find detailed information about each provider, including why they stood out to us.

Our Top 16 Car Insurance Agencies in NYC

  1. Regency Agency Inc.

    • Location: 8114 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11209
    • License: 672112
    • Ratings: Google (4.5/13 reviews), Facebook (5.0/11 reviews), Yelp (5.0/1 review)
    • Why Choose Them? Serving NYC since 1979, Regency Agency offers personalized auto insurance plans for both private and commercial clients. Founded by Anthony Aquilino, a well-respected figure in the insurance industry, the agency is known for its customer-focused approach.

  2. Haller-Zaremba Insurance Services

    • Location: 328 Hillside Ave, Williston Park, NY 11596
    • Ratings: Google (5.0/54 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? As an independent agency, Haller-Zaremba represents a wide range of reputable insurance companies, offering fairly priced auto insurance products. They excel at explaining complex insurance terms and tailoring coverage to meet individual needs.

  3. Mackoul Risk Solutions Insurance

    • Location: 25 W 64th St Apt 4A, New York, NY 10023
    • Ratings: Google (4.9/101 reviews), Facebook (5.0/50 reviews), Yelp (5.0/4 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? Offering comprehensive insurance solutions, Mackoul Risk Solutions focuses on protecting clients' assets with robust auto insurance policies. They also provide home, renters, and umbrella insurance.

  4. Vavas Insurance & Financial Services

    • Location: 8423 3rd Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11209
    • License: 1319807
    • Ratings: Google (5.0/64 reviews), Facebook (5.0/10 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? Vavas Insurance provides customized auto insurance policies, including liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. They also offer additional protection options like medical payments and emergency road service.

  5. Boynton & Boynton

    • Location: 21 Cedar Avenue, Fair Haven, NJ 07704
    • License: 786986
    • Ratings: Facebook (5.0/9 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? With nearly 90 years in the business, Boynton & Boynton has a large team of licensed professionals offering tailored insurance programs. They represent 32 insurance companies, ensuring a wide range of options for their clients.

  6. Sammy Brokerage, Inc.

    • Location: 41-01 Broadway, Astoria, NY 11103
    • License: 784681
    • Why Choose Them? This independent agency specializes in car, taxi, and limousine insurance, among others. With over 25 years in the industry, they offer services in multiple languages, including Polish, Hindi, Punjabi, and Arabic.

  7. Campbell Solberg Associates

    • Location: 129 W 27th St #6, New York, NY 10001
    • Ratings: Facebook (5.0/14 reviews), Google (5.0/1 review)
    • Why Choose Them? Known for fair and honest transactions, Campbell Solberg offers comprehensive auto insurance, including coverage for bodily injury, property damage, and uninsured motorists. They also cater to renters, homeowners, and businesses.

  8. Silver Lining Insurance

    • Location: 120 Broadway, 37th Floor, New York, NY 10271
    • License: 1600351
    • Ratings: Google (4.2/10 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? Silver Lining Insurance tailors insurance solutions for various vehicles, including motorcycles and RVs. Led by Michael Silverman, a seasoned professional, the agency offers customized policies from both national and regional carriers.

  9. Ability Service Agency

    • Location: 2075 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510
    • Ratings: Facebook (5.0/20 reviews), Google (4.4/8 reviews), Yelp (5.0/1 review)
    • Why Choose Them? Serving the New York metro area since 1975, Ability Service Agency provides comprehensive auto insurance options, including coverage for legal and medical expenses related to accidents. They also offer insurance for motorcycles, boats, and homes.

  10. Consumers Coverage Corp.

    • Location: 7512 Roosevelt Ave, Jackson Heights, NY 11372
    • Ratings: Google (5.0/29 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? With over 30 years of experience, Consumers Coverage Corp. sources auto insurance from several major providers. They offer tailored coverage for both individual and commercial clients, including fleet vehicles.

  11. Otterstedt Insurance Agency

    • Location: 540 Sylvan Ave, Englewood Cliffs, NJ 07632
    • Ratings: Facebook (4.9/57 reviews), Google (4.7/36 reviews), Yelp (3.0/2 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? Established in 1919, Otterstedt offers a variety of auto insurance policies, including coverage for motorcycles and trucks. They also provide homeowners and renters insurance, ensuring clients receive comprehensive coverage.

  12. DCAP Insurance

    • Location: 1839 Central Park Ave, Yonkers, NY 10710
    • Why Choose Them? DCAP Insurance offers a range of coverage options, from minimum liability to full collision protection. They specialize in comparing rates from multiple carriers to find clients the best deals.

  13. Tri State Insurance Brokerage

    • Location: 277 Tarrytown Rd, White Plains, NY 10607
    • Ratings: Facebook (5.0/9 reviews), Google (4.1/7 reviews), Yelp (5.0/1 review)
    • Why Choose Them? Serving the New York metro area, Tri-State Insurance Brokerage offers competitive rates from top carriers. They also provide specialty insurance options like earthquake and flood coverage.

  14. Meilee Fu - State Farm

    • Location: 139 Centre Street, Suite 813, New York, NY 10013
    • License: 738674
    • Ratings: Google (4.9/211 reviews), Facebook (4.9/25 reviews), Yelp (4.5/12 reviews)
    • Why Choose Them? A seasoned State Farm agent, Meilee Fu offers a wide range of insurance products, including auto, home, and life insurance. She caters to a diverse clientele and is bilingual in English and Chinese.

  15. Blue Rock Insurance Services

    • Location: 13505 38th Ave Apt 2A, Flushing, NY 11354
    • Ratings: Facebook (4.8/17 reviews), Google (5.0/7 reviews), Yelp (5.0/1 review)
    • Why Choose Them? Founded in 2015, Blue Rock Insurance specializes in providing comprehensive auto coverage at competitive prices. They also offer home, travel, and umbrella insurance.

  16. Mazzeo Agency Inc.

    • Location: 110 Wall St Fl 11, New York, NY 10005
    • Why Choose Them? With over 150 years of experience, Mazzeo Agency provides a full range of auto insurance solutions. They work with a variety of reputable carriers to offer clients tailored policies that meet their unique needs and budgets.

Learn More About Our Selection Process

Choosing the right car insurance agency can make a significant difference in your financial security and peace of mind. For more details on how we evaluated and selected these top agencies, feel free to explore our comprehensive research and methodology. We've done the hard work, so you can drive with confidence knowing you're well-protected!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Agency vs. Online

Image
  Agency vs. Online   Everyone loves to shop for a bargain, a discount, a reduced price, more features for less money.  One might also say, “You don’t get what you don’t pay for.” When you’re buying insurance, the “don’t get” part and the “don’t pay for” part can lead to you paying a lot more money than you bargained for later on when you need the insurance the most.  Your insurance is supposed to be there to anticipate risks to your life, your livelihood, your wealth and your health.  If you pay for less coverage because you need to get that bargain price, you’re putting all of the above at serious risk. Time is money.  Spend your time with an independent insurance agent.  The independent agent is working for your best interest, both in today’s premium pricing and in tomorrows unforeseen costs.  For me, it’s difficult to be objective on this topic. I’m an independent agent in business for several decades. I can’t b...
Read more

Acceptance Auto Insurance Reviews

Image
  Acceptance Auto Insurance Reviews Acceptance auto insurance often offers competitive rates to drivers who struggle to find affordable coverage from other providers. The company markets its insurance policies to young motorists, high-risk drivers and those with bad credit. While others may find better rates and coverage elsewhere, Acceptance auto insurance might be the right choice for specific motorists. We at the MarketWatch Guides Team looked into the coverage, cost and customer reviews of Acceptance auto insurance. Then, we compared it with the best car insurance companies to determine whether it’s a strong contender. It’s always smart to compare auto coverage from providers to discover which policies best fit your needs. Acceptance Insurance Review We give Acceptance auto insurance 7 .3 stars out of 10 . The company doesn’t offer the most reliable coverage in the industry, but it does provide necessary protection f...
Read more

Should You Bundle Your Home and Auto Insurance?

Image
  Should You Bundle Your Home and Auto Insurance? Buying homeowners insurance and auto insurance can be a good idea if doing so will save you money while providing the coverage you need. Bundling can also make it easier to manage your insurance payments. Home and auto insurance provide peace of mind, but high insurance premiums can leave you feeling financially frazzled. Bundling your home and auto insurance can help you save money and make it easier to manage your insurance policies. Bundling means buying two or more insurance policies from the same insurance company. Home and auto insurance are frequently bundled types of coverage, likely because bundling these policies typically generates big savings. However, you may also be able to bundle life insurance, renters insurance, condo insurance or insurance for motorcycles and boats. These other combinations can save you money too. Benefits of Bundling Your Home and Auto Insurance There are several potential ben...
Read more